On average, State Farm is 32% cheaper than Progressive. Young drivers can save $323 per month with State Farm, which makes it the best car insurance for teen drivers. Likewise, a driver with one prior accident will save 46% with State Farm compared to Progressive.

State Farm has significantly lower prices than Allstate across the board. You'll save hundreds or even thousands of dollars a year with State Farm depending on the policy you buy and your background. For example, a teen driver will save $4,620 per year on average by switching from Allstate to State Farm.